Waterwheel Village Menu (Update 2025)

At Waterwheel Village in Galway, NY, cheese lovers rejoice in a century-old tradition of crafting exceptional NY Cheddar since 1923. The shop is famous for its wide selection of cheeses, nostalgic candies, and delicious pies. Customers rave about the authentic cheddar cheese, unique candy offerings, and helpful staff. The owner's dedication to quality is evident in every purchase, from the Snappy Sharp Cheese to the Mourningkill Farm pies. Make sure to grab some sea salt caramels, clove gum, and a pack of crackers for a complete cheese plate experience. Waterwheel Village is not just a cheese shop; it's a destination for those seeking the finest artisanal treats. Don't miss out on this hidden gem – plan your visit today and indulge in the exceptional flavors that have delighted customers for decades.